ITW FB Cover Photo JPG

Leading up to The Kelsey Awards on Saturday, July 25th, we will be highlighting the five musicals nominated for Outstanding Production of a Musical. Today, we’ll take a glance at The Pennington Players production of Into the Woods.

KelseyExtra: Click Here To Get Your Tickets For The 2015 Kelsey Awards Before They Sell Out!


Director Kyrus Keenan Westcott Journey (foreground) journeys “Into the Woods” with cast members, front row, from left, Karl Weigand, Natalie Romeo, Ben Menahem, Kara Wilson, and Julie Stein; back row, from left, Frank Ferrara, Jenn Winn, John Zimmerman, Misha Barker, Christina Kosyla, Bill Weir, Kyla Donnelly Mostello, Taylor Lloyd and Jenna O’Neill.

In January 2015, the forest was deep and delightful in Into the Woods, which was presented by The Pennington Players inside The Kelsey Theatre.

With beguiling lyrics, sumptuous melodies, and a deliciously wicked plot, this Kelsey Award nominated and Tony Award winning Stephen Sondheim musical weaved together our favorite fairy tales as it picked up where “happily ever after” leaves off. Beloved characters such as Cinderella, her wicked stepmother and stepsisters, Little Red Riding Hood, Jack, Rapunzel, and the Princes are all drawn into the lives of a baker and his wife. The couple’s wish to start a family sets in motion a series of twisted events within the confines of the woods that charmed audiences one and all.

Kyrus Keenan Westcott, the production’s director and choreographer, notes that the Pennington Players’ production came just after the release of the film adaptation. “Audiences had a unique opportunity to see Into the Woods in two different mediums,” he said. “Our stage production offers the power of live theater performed in Kelsey’s uniquely intimate setting. We had no doubt that theater-goers would be fully immersed in this unforgettable story.”


The Baker (John Zimmerman) and his wife (Kara Wilson)

The cast featured Misha Barker of Plainsboro as Rapunzel; Kyla Mostello Donnelly of Levittown, Pa., as Cinderella’s stepmother; Frank Ferrara of West Windsor as the Steward; Christina Kosyla of Lawrence as Cinderella; Taylor Lloyd of Hamilton as Lucinda; Ben Menahem  of Plainsboro as Cinderella’s Prince; Jenna O’Neill of Hamilton as The Witch; Kevin Palardy of Doylestown, Pa., as Rapunzel’s Prince; Natalie Romeo of Piscataway as Little Red Riding Hood; E. Nicole Spadafino of Flemington as Milky White Puppeteer; Julie Stein of Monroe as Florinda; Karl Weigand of Lawrence as Jack; Bill Weir of Chalfont, Pa., as the Narrator; Kara Wilson of Rahway as the Baker’s Wife; Jennifer Winn of Ewing as Jack’s Mother; and John Zimmerman of Hamilton as the Baker.

Christina Kosyla as "Cinderella"
Christina Kosyla as “Cinderella”

In addition to Westcott, the production team included musical director Mike Gilch, set designer Bryan Schendlinger, costumer designer Rusty Miller, stage manager Sally Page and Vianna Fagel, sound designer Wayne Irons, lighting designer Vicki Kaiser, and properties by Dottie Farina.


  • Ben Menahem as "Cinderella's Prince"
    Ben Menahem as “Cinderella’s Prince”

    Outstanding Sound Design

  • Outstanding Lighting Design
  • Outstanding Costume & Make-up Design
  • Outstanding Set & Scenic Design
  • Outstanding Vocal & Music Direction
  • Outstanding Direction of a Musical
  • Outstanding Comedic Performance (Ben Menahem & Kevin Palardy as “The Princes”)
  • Singer of the Year (Jenna O’Neill as “The Witch”)
  • Outstanding Kelsey Theatre Debut (Kara Wilson as “The Baker’s Wife”)
  • Outstanding Kelsey Theatre Debut (Christina Kosyla as “Cinderella”)
  • Outstanding Musical Number (“Children Will Listen/Finale”)
  • Villain of the Year (Jenna O’Neill as “The Witch”)
  • Outstanding Theatrical Romantic Couple (John Zimmerman & Kara Wilson as “The Baker” & “The Baker’s Wife”)
  • Outstanding Young Performer (Jenna O’Neill as “The Witch”)
  • Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Musical (Christina Kosyla as “Cinderella”)
  • Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical (Jenna O’Neill as “The Witch”)
  • Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical (Kara Wilson as “The Baker’s Wife”)
  • Outstanding Lead Actor in a Musical (John Zimmerman as “The Baker”)
  • Outstanding Production of a Musical

Will Into the Woods walk away with any Kelsey Awards? Find out during the live ceremony on Saturday, July 25th at 8pm! CLICK HERE to get your tickets before they sell out!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s